How It Should Have Turned Out

When I was in college had a chance encounter with a guy in the locker room. I've already posted the story of how it went in reality. But this is my fantasy of what might have happened! I hope you like it. It's my first fictional story.

Just to set the scene, I'll retell some of what was in the other story.

I was on a sports team in college and we had a small "private" room that shared an open-room shower and bathroom with another team whose small locker room was adjacent to ours. I was always bi-curious. But very shy. I was also a complete virgin at the time.

At the end of practice one Friday afternoon I was with only one other teammate just finishing dressing after our showers. A guy had apparently entered the next door locker room for the other sports team, and entered the shower room. I noticed him and recognized him from other times in the main locker room. He was cute, brown hair, brown eyes, slim, about my height, not very muscular, just right! He had some jewelry, which sort of intrigued me. 

I glanced at him as he was in the shower, not staring too much. Only I could see him from my location in our locker room. My teammate could not. I had my white briefs halfway up my legs, the rest of my body completely naked, when my teammate threw some socks at me. I was caught by surprise and swatted the socks away, my soft dick swinging about, flopping against my thighs, my briefs just above my knees. 

Very soon after that the guy in the shower turned off the water and walked right at me, as he had to in order to reach the open door into the other locker room. Only I could see him. As he came toward me I immediately saw that his cock was hard, sticking straight out and slightly up. But the most amazing thing to me was that it was pointing RIGHT AT ME!! I was mesmerized as it wiggled as he walked. I'm sure he was looking right at me, but I was watching his hard dick.

Soon after, my teammate left. I was still dressing. But then the dance began. The other guy walked back and forth between that other locker room and the bathroom, passing the door into my team's room and looking at me. He was still naked, but soft now.

I decided this was my time to have my first sex! I started to take off my sneakers and socks, then pants. The other guy was getting more and more interested and lingering near the door to my room, which was only 10 feet from me. 

(In real life, I chickened out at this stage, got dressed and after packing up my stuff, I left. I was too shy to actually go through with it. But now the fictional part starts.)

Once I was naked, I took my towel and shampoo and headed back toward the shower room. As I passed the other room's door, I turned and looked at the other guy. He was facing the other way, and I looked at his slim, dimpled, cute butt. He turned right at that time and caught me. I just continued on into the shower and started one of the shower heads going.

LIke 10 seconds later he appeared in the entrance to the shower room, and kinda not looking at me, he moved to a shower head, next to mine. He had about a half-dozen choices but he chose that one. Being shy, I was not staring directly at him, but glanced a few times. He had a nice semi now, as did I. I mumbled something about needing another shower, pretty lame, and he smiled a bit and said he needed another too. My heart was beating so fast. I got hard right away, then. And he did too. There his hard cock was again, wiggling about as he rinsed himself under the water. My breath was already kinda heavy and I was wondering what would happen next.

He said, "I'm Cody." I said, "I'm Taylor." He smiled again and reached out his hand. I shook it. He held on a bit more, then went back to stroking his torso under the shower. 

I softly said, "I've never had sex before." He quietly said, "Really? You are so cute." I quickly said, "You are cute too." I couldn't believe this was happening. I felt like I was outside my body observing this whole situation. I think he could see I was shy and not even sure what to do next. When he moved closer to me and reached out and touched my hip I was surprised at how that touch shot right through me. I must have not been breathing, but then I let out a loud sigh, and I touched his arm. He was looking right into my eyes.

I said, "I'm afraid someone will come in." I will forever remember how the next thing he said changed my life, "My roommate has gone home for the weekend. We could go to my room to hang out." I managed a little smile and nodded. We turned off the water, quickly dried off, and got dressed. It was very hot to watch his ass as he walked out of the locker room, his tight jeans perfectly framing it. I couldn't believe this was happening.

We walked across campus chatting about nothing all that important. But I was feeling more comfortable and managed to hold up my end of the conversation. He was a nice guy and he was clearly happy about what was going to happen, I thought.

When we got to his dorm, I was relieved to see there were no guys in the hallway. His room was a small double. Once we closed the door, we sat on his bed a bit and continued the chat about school and the campus. But then it was quiet a bit and he reached out and put his hand on my thigh. We were kinda facing each other. I remember the warmth of his hand. My cock, which had shriveled up a bit during the "normal" walk, was instantly straining at my briefs and jeans.

We were naked pretty quickly. I don't remember taking anything off. He immediately took hold of my hard dick. So I held his. We were now on his bed. His body was against mine, so warm, and hard. While he stroked me I couldn't hold out for long. I let go of his cock, and he sped up on me. Within about 30 seconds I shot 3 ropes all over my chest and dribbled down on his hand. He let me relax as he held my softening dick. It didn't go all the way down. I wanted to see him cum too, so I started stroking him again. I thought it was so interesting how he was so hard, yet the skin on his dick was so soft. And his hard dick was very warm. Holding and stoking someone else's boner was just so interesting. Not sure that's the right word, but it's close. Then with a big sigh and moan he stiffened and shot cum up on his chest. It also flowed done on my hand. He had to stop me from stroking him as he must have been very sensitive after that. I laid next to him wondering what was next.

Finally, he grabbed his t-shirt and wiped himself and me.

I think it lasted maybe 15 minutes from when we entered his room to us laying there recovering.

He said he had fun and asked me what I thought. He clearly had more experience than me. I was still recovering from the whole idea of finally doing something with someone! I told him it was really fun. Then he kissed me. It was just a quick peck on the lips as he held my face. I was floored. This was nothing I was expecting. I hadn't thought beyond the idea of cumming with a guy. But I have to say it felt nice and it made me like him a lot. He was gentle with me and made me feel good, and wanted.

I left soon after that. But we both said we'd like to meet up again. I'm kinda romantic by nature and I thought about him for a while. Then, since we had exchanged contact info, I heard from him. He said his roommate was going home for the weekend again, and would I like to hang out. Wow, my heart jumped, and I said I would really like that.

That night, in his room, I tasted cum for the first time. It was not all that great, but it was his and so I liked it. When his lips touched my cock I couldn't believe how electrifying it was. When I came he kept his mouth on me until I was soft. I was so sensitive but it felt so good.

I stayed that night. And many others. Cody changed my life. I never thought of myself as bi until Cody. I thought I was just horny.

He even came to my games. And my teammates were very accepting when they figured out I had a boyfriend.